Mental Health vs. Mental Toughness

Understanding the Difference, Why Both Matter for Athletes & avoiding the victim mindset

At the heart of every athlete’s journey, there is an undeniable drive to win. But to succeed at a high level, athletes must understand that success is not determined only by physical ability or technical skill—it is rooted in the strength of the mind.

In the world of sports, the terms “mental health” and “mental toughness” are often used interchangeably. However, they are two distinct concepts that intersect in ways that can have a profound impact on an athlete’s performance and overall well-being. To truly understand how to thrive, athletes need to recognize the difference, know why both matter, and embrace the balance between them.

Mental Health: The Foundation of Well-Being

Mental health refers to a person’s emotional, psychological, and social well-being. It encompasses how we think, feel, and behave in our daily lives, and it directly influences how we handle stress, relate to others, and make decisions. For athletes, mental health is crucial—not just for performance, but for overall health. Mental health issues like anxiety, depression, burnout, and stress can affect an athlete’s ability to perform, focus, and recover.

While highly stigmatized, mental health challenges are common in the sporting world, often linked to the pressures of competition, fear of failure, or expectations from coaches, fans, and family. Research from the Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology (2019) highlighted that athletes are particularly susceptible to mental health challenges due to the high-stress environments they face. A 2019 study by Gouttebarge et al. found that nearly 35% of athletes experience some form of mental health issue, with anxiety and depression being the most common.

Additionally, a study by Reardon and Factor (2010) in the Journal of Clinical Sports Psychology reported that athletes often face a “mental health paradox,” where high levels of performance expectations contribute to a high incidence of depression, anxiety, and burnout. This indicates that addressing mental health early is crucial for athletes to maintain peak performance and well-being.

Mental Toughness: The Psychological Edge

Mental toughness, on the other hand, is the psychological edge that helps athletes perform under pressure, push through adversity, and persevere in the face of setbacks. It is the ability to stay focused, maintain confidence, and recover quickly from challenges—whether that’s a missed shot, an injury, or a tough game.

But mental toughness is not about being immune to stress or emotions. It’s about how athletes respond to those feelings. According to Clough, Earle, and Sewell (2002), mental toughness involves characteristics like perseverance, emotional control, and resilience. Athletes with mental toughness are better able to cope with stress, stay confident, and maintain focus, especially during high-pressure situations. A mentally tough athlete can experience failure, doubt, or fatigue but can still perform when it matters most. They acknowledge the difficulty, then dig deep and use those challenges as fuel to push harder.

The Intersection: Where Mental Health Meets Mental Toughness

While mental health and mental toughness are distinct, they are not mutually exclusive. In fact, they intersect in powerful ways. A strong mental health foundation enables athletes to build mental toughness. Without proper mental health, the foundation for developing resilience, grit, and perseverance is compromised.

When athletes have a healthy mental state, they are better equipped to build the emotional endurance necessary for mental toughness. Healthy coping mechanisms, emotional regulation, and the ability to self-reflect all contribute to resilience. In contrast, an athlete struggling with mental health issues may find it harder to tap into their mental toughness, especially when faced with setbacks.

The Victim Mindset: A Misconception About Mental Health in Sport

The victim mindset can significantly hinder an athlete’s progress, particularly when mental health struggles are misunderstood as weakness. Athletes who adopt a victim mentality feel powerless in the face of adversity, blaming external factors like their coach’s decisions, circumstances, or bad luck, instead of taking ownership of how they respond. While mental health challenges are real and need to be addressed, the victim mindset prevents athletes from recognizing the opportunities for growth within their struggles. Research by Seligman (1990) on learned helplessness shows how repeated failure can lead to a passive mindset, decreasing motivation and resilience. It’s important to understand that while mental health issues require support and care, mental toughness is what helps athletes avoid becoming victims of their situations, teaching them to push through challenges when needed without ignoring their emotional well-being.

Understanding the intersection of mental health and mental toughness is crucial. Mental health challenges, such as anxiety or depression, can sometimes prevent an athlete from performing at their best, and addressing these issues is vital for long-term well-being. However, mental toughness helps athletes avoid becoming trapped in a mindset of helplessness. Athletes with mental toughness know when it’s time to push through a challenge or setback, recognizing that not every obstacle is an indication of failure. This ability to navigate adversity is reinforced by a growth mindset, where setbacks are seen as opportunities for growth rather than proof of inadequacy. Research by Gouttebarge et al. (2019) highlights that athletes who embrace mental toughness while addressing their mental health concerns are more resilient and able to perform under pressure, ultimately leading to greater success both in and out of the arena.

Why It’s Important to Know the Difference

Understanding the difference between mental health and mental toughness is essential for athletes, coaches, and sports organizations alike. Recognizing when an athlete is struggling with their mental health, rather than just lacking mental toughness, can be the key to getting the right support. The stigma surrounding mental health in sports has led many athletes to push through challenges without seeking help, believing that they simply need to "toughen up."

But here’s the truth: mental health challenges require care, and mental toughness can’t be built without first addressing mental well-being. An athlete who is mentally unwell cannot perform at their best, no matter how tough they are. Similarly, an athlete who is mentally tough but has unresolved mental health issues may face long-term consequences—both for their performance and their personal life.

Why Both Are Important for Athletes

For athletes to reach their full potential, they must cultivate both mental health and mental toughness.

Mental Health Fuels Longevity: When an athlete takes care of their mental health, they are more likely to enjoy a long and sustainable career. Healthy coping mechanisms for stress and recovery from failure will help them stay grounded, reducing the risk of burnout, injury, and emotional exhaustion.
Mental Toughness Powers Performance: Mental toughness is critical in high-pressure moments—whether that’s a game-deciding shot, a close race, or a challenging season. The ability to stay focused, believe in yourself, and keep pushing through adversity can be the difference between victory and defeat.
Building a Stronger Self: Together, mental health and mental toughness shape a resilient athlete—someone who is not only capable of achieving great things on the field but also of handling the ups and downs of life off it.

Mental health gives athletes the tools to navigate life’s challenges with grace and resilience. Mental toughness ensures they rise to meet those challenges with strength and determination. By nurturing both, athletes cultivate a mind that is capable of overcoming any obstacle while maintaining the emotional strength to bounce back after any setback.

Conclusion

At The Athlete Confidential, we believe that athletes are human first and athletes second. This means we prioritize mental health alongside mental toughness. We honor the fact that being tough is not about enduring pain or hardship in silence, but about having the strength to care for yourself, to ask for help when needed, and to persevere despite the difficulties you face.

The intersection of mental health and mental toughness is where true strength lies. An athlete who embraces both is unstoppable—driven by resilience, grounded in well-being, and prepared to take on any challenge that comes their way.

References:

Clough, P. J., Earle, K., & Sewell, D. (2002). Mental toughness: The concept and its measurement. Personality and Individual Differences, 32(4), 569-581.
Gouttebarge, V., Frings-Dresen, M. H. W., & Sluiter, J. K. (2019). Prevalence and risk factors of mental health symptoms among athletes: A systematic review. Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology, 13(3), 217-247.
Jones, G., Hanton, S., & Connaughton, D. (2007). A framework of mental toughness in the world’s best performers. The Sport Psychologist, 21(2), 243-264.
Reardon, C. L., & Factor, R. M. (2010). Sport psychiatry: The mental health care of the athlete. The Journal of Clinical Sports Psychology, 24(3), 201-211.
Reardon, C. L., & Perkins, T. A. (2020). The mental health needs of athletes: Interventions and treatment. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 18(2), 127-142.
Seligman, M. E. P. (1990). Learned optimism: How to change your mind and your life. Vintage Books.

SHOP